In waiting for the cinematic recap for the Florida game earlier today, I thought it would be fun to go back and rank all of the cinematic recaps from this season. I'm a really big nerd when it comes to video editing and production so I really enjoy these and watch them multiple times to take everything in. I know you all enjoy them as well so I'm interested to see if any of you have any particular feelings.
#12
Virginia Tech - It just didn't move me. I think that it was just the overall composition of the shots. There were some really cool one shot tracks of players but overall, it felt thrown together and the music felt very standard.
Login to view embedded media
#11
Wake Forest - This recap was just all over the place. Tone and pacing, everything felt so stop and go. Probably didn't need to be 8 minutes long. Some cool tidbits with Norvell and Dave Clausen, Keon and Benson. Other than that, it felt like it just didn't have a direction.
Login to view embedded media
#10
Boston College - Really short. Really meh. I felt like a lot of the recap was detoured to the postgame locker room speech by Norvell to let fans hear what he told the team after a close call. It's a choice I completely understand but it's also something that objectively just makes the recap not very enjoyable or memorable on subsequent viewings.
Login to view embedded media
#9
Syracuse - At first glance, I thought I was going to really like this recap. The vibe was different and I enjoyed the more bragadocious music selection but then the recap didn't really feel like it started until the Keon Coleman one handed catch. I know it's difficult when the game you are recapping was a blow out but I felt like choosing to have no music and just the warchant for a solid minute just made me lose interest. Another recap that could have been 5 minutes instead of 8.
Login to view embedded media
#8
Southern Mississippi - Similar criticism of the Syracuse recap in terms of how it started but I felt like the overall composition of the footage in the recap was much better - much more consistent. I felt like this recap did a better job of keeping your attention, which upon multiple viewings is important. I would watch this again, some others not so much.
Login to view embedded media
#7
North Alabama - The way it handled recapping Jordan's injury was perfect. The way that it handled Jameis and senior day was great as well. The juxaposition between senior day, the ceremony and then the injury. The audio cuts to white noise. The speeches by Odell and YAC were wonderfully implemented and the somberness of the soundtrack for the rest of the recap felt well-placed. The Norvell speech over the 2013 ceremony was cool as well. It treated a very delicate matter very well.
Login to view embedded media
#6
Miami - I had to watch this one a couple of times because I couldnt decided how I wanted to rank it. I think what I like the most about it was its simplicity. It sets the stage and intensity so well with the intro by Jermaine Johnson and the soundtrack early on. But then, most of the recap is game volume, announcing and stadium sound which I felt was really appropriate for this game in particular. I don't think it would have worked for other games. When there was music, it was mostly drums and strings... no loud horns. It really told you the story of the game without the theatrics and it felt more grounded. The one thing that kept it from being higher was that I felt the recap was too long - even for a rivalry recap.
Login to view embedded media
#5
Clemson - I'm going to be honest. This one is probably going to be a lot of people's favorite. It has a lot of great moments. The slow-motion, silent audio shots of both the Coleman touchdown and the DeLoach strip-six. But other than that, the thing that drags the recap to me is the main musical theme. I was not a fan of it. It comes down to personal preference here. There was another interluding track in this recap with a nice piano theme that I think I would have preferred but it doesn't bring the intensity that the other track does.
Login to view embedded media
#4
Florida - Oh my goodness the cinematography in this recap was spectacular. So many shots that made my jaw drop and I went back to watch again. And so many small moments that you really appreciate. The moments shared between Jordan and Tate / Jared that you would imagine happened but couldn't visualize are there. Norvell's speech heading into the locker room at halftime. "I know you've got it!". The soundtrack is a nice middle ground - not too overbearing but not unnoticeable. Similar to Miami, I think it was too long but this recap does a much better job at telling the story of the game - and there was definitely more to tell.
Login to view embedded media
#3
Pitt - I was surprised how much I loved this recap. It was shorter, it was sweet - but it was so effective. The consistency of the audio was key here. The strings of the soundtrack, the use of audio-visual sound on the down beats in the early portions of the recap, and the continuation of that throughout the video. And it's the small things, the interactions between players and coaches. Ja'Khi Douglas screaming he loves Norvell as they embrace on the sideline, the interaction between Douglas and Benson... and yes... Garnet the Goldfish. Great recap.
Login to view embedded media
#2
LSU - The storytelling here was some of the best of the season. It helps that SemPro had a little bit more time to plan for this recap but I love pratically everything about the presentation. The contextual setup. The choice of music in the beginning that sounds like a clock ticking down to what would be a special season. The long shot of Norvell leaving the tunnel and taking a deep breath - showing some anxiety in the moment as he prepares himself for a big game. The showing that even though Norvell is the head of the program, even he needs to take a moment to collect himself. The audio bite of Odell at halftime. The pacing of the footage, the music selection and the pure joy on Keon's face as he breaks the rock. Priceless. This is one I will keep coming back to. It so perfectly captured the emotion of the game and the how much it weighed / meant to the players.
Login to view embedded media
#1
Duke - I felt like this recap was perfect. It captured the emotion of the game perfectly with the shot composition, the pacing and the music choice. The shot of the helicopters flying over, the Seminole Heritage night activities... really cool stuff. I'm partial to more orchestral music in these recaps rather than something that is very in your face and this recap really tugged at the emotion of the game. The alternating between the interstellar-esque string piece and the more triumphant full orchestra piece was perfect. The kick-return by Deuce Spann with that music makes the hair on your arms stand up. This recap really embodied and embraced the resilient attitude of the team and this is one that is fantastic on subsequent viewings.
Login to view embedded media
Interested to read your thoughts if you have any. These recaps have been something to look forward to every Monday and as someone who really enjoys the creative production side of things, they always were interesting to see.