ADVERTISEMENT

Beaches are hurting

billanole

Veteran Seminole Insider
Mar 5, 2005
9,896
3,882
853
and the Corps of Engineers are holding off on some replenishment projects. Interesting read.

In response to questions from Grist, a spokesperson for the Corps gave no indication that the agency will budge on its policy, which it has begun to enforce elsewhere in Florida and in other coastal states like South Carolina.
Even when Pinellas County tried to obtain separate temporary easements to build new emergency dunes at the top of its beaches, many residents still refused, in part out of a concern that new dunes would block their ocean views. This further stalemate with homeowners has forced the county to build a piecemeal dune behind coastal properties, leaving holes in front of the homes and hotels where the owners didn’t want to grant an easement.
This broken dune won’t do much come storm season, according to René Flowers, a Pinellas County commissioner who has been pushing the Corps to deliver the sand.
“When you have a break in the chain, then all of the work that you’re doing is not as impactful in protecting as it would be,” she said.
Rob Young, a professor of geology at Western Carolina University and a frequent critic of beach nourishment projects, says Pinellas County should fund the nourishment itself through sales tax increases rather than relying on the federal government to pay for new sand. He pointed out that some beach towns on the Outer Banks of North Carolina have taxed tourism to pay for sand after the federal government stopped covering the costs.
“For a lot of people, the privacy is more important to them than the risk of destruction,” he said, referring to residents who refused to grant easements. “The solution is very easy—pay for your own risk.” Young added that many nourishment projects don’t seem to be worth the money they cost. He pointed to the Jersey Shore, where a $1 million beach nourishment project washed away in just one year.
The knowledge that beach nourishment might not be a good investment doesn’t do much to help local leaders like Flowers, the Pinellas County commissioner, who is bracing herself for a hurricane season that meteorologists predict will be one of the most active in decades.
 
Last edited:
and the Corps of Engineers are holding off on some replenishment projects. Interesting read.

In response to questions from Grist, a spokesperson for the Corps gave no indication that the agency will budge on its policy, which it has begun to enforce elsewhere in Florida and in other coastal states like South Carolina.
Even when Pinellas County tried to obtain separate temporary easements to build new emergency dunes at the top of its beaches, many residents still refused, in part out of a concern that new dunes would block their ocean views. This further stalemate with homeowners has forced the county to build a piecemeal dune behind coastal properties, leaving holes in front of the homes and hotels where the owners didn’t want to grant an easement.
This broken dune won’t do much come storm season, according to René Flowers, a Pinellas County commissioner who has been pushing the Corps to deliver the sand.
“When you have a break in the chain, then all of the work that you’re doing is not as impactful in protecting as it would be,” she said.
Rob Young, a professor of geology at Western Carolina University and a frequent critic of beach nourishment projects, says Pinellas County should fund the nourishment itself through sales tax increases rather than relying on the federal government to pay for new sand. He pointed out that some beach towns on the Outer Banks of North Carolina have taxed tourism to pay for sand after the federal government stopped covering the costs.
“For a lot of people, the privacy is more important to them than the risk of destruction,” he said, referring to residents who refused to grant easements. “The solution is very easy—pay for your own risk.” Young added that many nourishment projects don’t seem to be worth the money they cost. He pointed to the Jersey Shore, where a $1 million beach nourishment project washed away in just one year.
The knowledge that beach nourishment might not be a good investment doesn’t do much to help local leaders like Flowers, the Pinellas County commissioner, who is bracing herself for a hurricane season that meteorologists predict will be one of the most active in decades.
There isn't some sort of "imminent domain" law the county or state could use to get this done? I'm not a fan of this type thing but if erosion is an issue and these dunes could protect property then why not? However, if they really are not a long-term solution maybe it should be back to the drawing board.
 
There isn't some sort of "imminent domain" law the county or state could use to get this done? I'm not a fan of this type thing but if erosion is an issue and these dunes could protect property then why not? However, if they really are not a long-term solution maybe it should be back to the drawing board.
Dunes, mangroves, wetlands, and other native plant life were always the best protection, but they get in the way of access and visibility. They also inhabit space that peeps wanna develop. Case in point, Cape Coral.

Hard scape such as sea walls, jetties, etc… increase the damage to the property down the way and eventually fail. Going back to the drawing board means giving space to the natural solutions.
 
Don’t think that beaches and their first world issues are the only thing in the path.

Much infrastructure is very susceptible to waterborne destruction. Military infrastructure in particular…
Please explain the military infrastructure part.
 
Dunes, mangroves, wetlands, and other native plant life were always the best protection, but they get in the way of access and visibility. They also inhabit space that peeps wanna develop. Case in point, Cape Coral.

Hard scape such as sea walls, jetties, etc… increase the damage to the property down the way and eventually fail. Going back to the drawing board means giving space to the natural solutions.
Big condo and all its added people vs another dune or natural solution? I'll take the natural solution.
 
  • Like
Reactions: trunole1 and F4Gary
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT