ADVERTISEMENT

Italian restaurants Tallahassee?

Dr. Nole

Ultimate Seminole Insider
Gold Member
Sep 13, 2002
19,724
20,189
1,853
Wife and I will be in Tally this weekend for the NCSt game.
Like to go out Friday night for a nice dinner.
Staying at the Gaines street Residence inn.

Italian is always a good choice for us...like to avoid the chain ones (Carrabas, Olive Garden sort of places)

Any ideas?
Also recommendations in general anyone has, not just Italian.
thx
 
Wife and I will be in Tally this weekend for the NCSt game.
Like to go out Friday night for a nice dinner.
Staying at the Gaines street Residence inn.

Italian is always a good choice for us...like to avoid the chain ones (Carrabas, Olive Garden sort of places)

Any ideas?
Also recommendations in general anyone has, not just Italian.
thx

Gwinnett isn't too far off. We really have zero Italian places (and I've been to all of the ones mentioned, Bella Bella seems to be most popular in town but it's very bland and Ricardos was pretty bad the two times I've been well below chains) in town that are substantially better than commercial chains like Olive Garden or Carabas. I honestly will drive to Perry for the slightly above average quality of Mama's.

If you HAVE to have Italian, the best overall imo is Little Italy but there's nothing fantastic. Mom and Dad's meanwhile has a handful of dishes that I would consider 4 star out of 5 and therefore better than anything at Little Italy but you would have to stick to getting their homemade marinara and homemade meatballs with gnocchi that's pretty decent or one of their dried pastas. Other than that I would only consider Mom and Dad's rollatini as decent. The rest of their dishes are below Little Italy imo.

Now if you want Pizza there's tons of great choices like Isabella's Pizzaria Napoletana, Momo's, Gainesville Street Pies and the chains Blaze and Mellow Mushroom.

The best overall restaurants in town is Cypress and Avenue Eat and Drink with both having above average foodie food but nothing adventurous. For steak the best is the small chain Ted's Montana Grill which not only has great bison and free range grass fed beef steaks but pretty much all of their dishes are pretty good even their crabcakes, trout and other seafood dishes. Heck their bison pot roast is amazingly good.

The rest of the best I would say are mostly ethnic food like Tan's Asian Cafe for Indonesian (skip their "Chinese" and Japanese but do get the boba tea especially melon), Real Sarap for Filipino, Azu for generic Asian food and American "Chinese" food, Arepana for great arepas and even better fried yucca, La Tiendita for relatively authentic Mexican (the tongue, cabeza and crispy tripe tacos and the hibiscus Agua in particular are quite good) and Samrat for Indian are your best bets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tbdnole_70_08
Bella Bella is the best in tally, though slim pickings. Mom & Dads as well, but BB is better imo
 
I am a Mom and Dads fan. It says a lot they have stayed open so long in this town in that location.

They have the best sauce and lasagna in town, with numerous super thin pasta layers. Very happy they are opening a new location 3.5 miles from my house. I also like Bella Bella a lot. Next for me is Little Italy. I think they have best calazones in town. Again with the Mom and Dad's theme, with that meh location and as long as they have been open, you have to be doing something right in this fickle town.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phyrst1
I'll hijack this thread...best grub after 11:00 in Tally?

waffle-house.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: FSUTribe76
Wife and I will be in Tally this weekend for the NCSt game.
Like to go out Friday night for a nice dinner.
Staying at the Gaines street Residence inn.

Italian is always a good choice for us...like to avoid the chain ones (Carrabas, Olive Garden sort of places)

Any ideas?
Also recommendations in general anyone has, not just Italian.
thx


I can't really speak to the taste of their food, but considering your location I would have to say your best bet is Centrale, the scenery can't be beat.
 
I can't really speak to the taste of their food, but considering your location I would have to say your best bet is Centrale, the scenery can't be beat.
That may be it! Thank you...I didn't even see this place when I was looking for places we could walk to from hotel.
 
That may be it! Thank you...I didn't even see this place when I was looking for places we could walk to from hotel.
The food is ok. Not horrible, but not great either. The scenery will be good. I'd personally go with Bella Bella.
 
If any of you are ever in the Valdosta area go near the college / Valdosta State on Ann Street and try the Greek and Italian restaurant called Giulio's .
Owned by Greek people it's in a two-story old house which is a neat setting. They usually have some sort of light music going whether it be guitar or vocals. They have some good Greek food with real good ingredients. They also make a great sangria for those that like that.

You can go casual or a little dressier either-or. They have a few tables outside if the weather is right.

105 E. ANN ST.
 
That may be it! Thank you...I didn't even see this place when I was looking for places we could walk to from hotel.

Just a heads up, the walk is 1 mile. Also, they are having the "downtown getdown" in that area now, so there will be a band and stuff and it will be pretty crowded. Should be a fun atmosphere, but I wasn't sure if you were just looking for a low key dinner with your wife.
 
Just a heads up, the walk is 1 mile. Also, they are having the "downtown getdown" in that area now, so there will be a band and stuff and it will be pretty crowded. Should be a fun atmosphere, but I wasn't sure if you were just looking for a low key dinner with your wife.
Yeah I saw that.
I don't what we'll do.

The wife will be at her '80's sorority reunion "thing" from like 6-8 PM friday night so...I was thinking of finding a seat somewhere at one of the restaurants/bars at college town and she'd meet me there later. Of course now I'm the creepy middle aged man sitting alone amongst a zillion college aged kids. I don't know where I'll park my van...
 
Z Bardhi's in Killearn is decent but Tally has not had great Italian since Nino's closed..I drive up to Thomasville Mom and Dad's when I want some good Red Sauce Italian as the one on the Parkway has not been good since Gene sold it
 
Good Italian food in Tallahassee? LMAO

Yeah. To some extent I was already thinking arguing about what's the best Italian in Tally is like arguing which is the best giant fast food chain burger, The Big Mac, Whopper, SuperSonic, etc... Yeah one might be the better to someone's particular taste...but it's all cr^#. I joined in because I will even argue McDonalds versus Sonic and I do think BellaBella is ridiculously overrated by fellow townies but I frequently go back to visit my parents in Hernando County which has maybe even a dozen better Italian and Sicilian places than Tally's best and Hernando is a pretty small county.

Unlike Mexican, where Tally has about 20 %*#*y TexMex places but DOES have one actually decent and mostly authentic Mexican place (La Tiendita), we really have zero in the way of passable Italian. Ditto Cuban no matter how appealing the "views" may be at Gordos. With all of the New Yawker transplants and all of the Tampons and Miamians in the area you would THINK we should have at least one really good Italian and one really good Cuban place...but you'd be wrong.

Tallahassee's food scene was absolutely terrible ten years ago and pretty bad even five years ago but in the last 3 or so years has really improved imo. We've gotten a bunch of pretty decent albeit unadventurous chef driven foodie places and we're starting to get some of the better smaller chain places like Blaze Pizza and Mission BBQ. No one is going to mistake Tally for a Charleston, Savannah, Asheville, or even Richmond level of small foodie town but it's no longer embarrassingly bad just...not good for a city of its prominence (excluding the dozen or so decent places).
 
  • Like
Reactions: nynole1
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT