ADVERTISEMENT

Question for military guys / veterans

billyfsu76

Contributor
Jan 2, 2004
2,185
57
653
Orlando, FL
Little background: I come from a family which, like a lot of people, had a relatively heavy dose of military participation. My great-grandparents on my dad's side were immigrants from Italy, settling in Brooklyn in the early 1900s.

My grandfather was one of six (five boys and a girl), all born in the U.S. Their cousins (two males) also lived in the same building. They all joined the U.S. military (a few of them together right after Pearl Harbor). From what I remember, two in the Marines, the rest in the Army, no one left alive knows why the split.

One of the cousins was killed in the Battle of the Bulge, but the other six made it. Two were given purple hearts (one from being wounded in N. Africa and the other in France). When I was a kid, these were in glass cases in my great-grandparents' house. A lot of families have stories like this.

My grandfather had two boys, but only my dad had children. I am the only son. Somewhat remarkably, out of all those four other brothers and the cousin who survived the war (all who had the same Italian last name), only two others other than my grandfather had children, and they were all girls (one had two daughters, the other just a single girl). Long story short, I am the only one (other than my father and his brother) with our last name in all of the U.S.

That being the case, I have always told people that my last name means a lot to me. My family knows this and, when my grandmother died recently and family members were cleaning out her house, someone found my grandfather's dog tags and put them on a simple silver chain and gave them to me for Christmas.

I think it's a really cool gift but I somehow feel very odd about wearing them, like it's disrespectful, and even somewhat lame, like I'm trying to pretend that I'm in the Army. None of those guys are left alive any longer (my grandfather was the youngest and he and his next older brother both died in the early 2000s). I don't know how they'd feel about it. Most of them stayed in the military after the war, at least few a few years. My grandfather was stationed in France and Germany through the early 50s but came back to the U.S. to work in NY and then retired in FL (which is where my parents moved to be close to them and where I was raised in the 80s-90s). My father was in the military during Vietnam also, but in the Air Force, stationed mostly in Thailand working on cargo planes.

I grew up in a family where military stories and a respect / admiration for the Army esp. were omnipresent. My granddad's Army blanket was on one of the beds in the guest room, he and his brothers all had a love of firearms and mechanics, all things they'd picked up from their time overseas, etc.

The family members that gave me the gift thinking that I should / would want to wear these tags. I really wish that some of those older relatives were around to tell me what they think but if anyone who has a similar family background has an opinion, please feel free to let me know. Thanks in advance.
 
Not a military guy but I say wear them and, if asked, admit that you never served but that the tags were your grandfathers. I think the issue would be with those who pretended to serve but didn't.
Posted from Rivals Mobile
 
Air Force Retired 22 years!! (My Opinion)

I think it's awesome that you have those precious family heirlooms; you should wear them proudly and explain them to everyone who asks why you have them on!! You will not be looked down upon, if you proudly state the truth! Many people have family heirlooms that are military related and proudly display them, you should too!
 
If you don't feel comfortable wearing them, but they do mean a lot to you, put them on display.

You could put them in a frame along with a picture of our grandfather and write up about his service. Maybe add a folded American flag with it as well. Would be a great opportunity to brag about his service when you have guest over without feeling like your leading others by wearing. Would look pretty sweet hanging on a wall as well if done right.

Them again, if you wear them, you never know when you might have a dinner picked up or drink on the house...could be granddad's way of saying, have one on me...just sayin.

I don't know, just suggestions.
Posted from Rivals Mobile
 
Originally posted by NoleFan28:
Air Force Retired 22 years!! (My Opinion)

I think it's awesome that you have those precious family heirlooms; you should wear them proudly and explain them to everyone who asks why you have them on!! You will not be looked down upon, if you proudly state the truth! Many people have family heirlooms that are military related and proudly display them, you should too!
I agree with the old fart.
3dgrin.r191677.gif
 
In that vein I have an heirloom of my grandfather's.

He joined the Marines in January of '42 and at the little depot where he signed the induction papers in Arkansas they gave him a 'postcard' that listed the date of his induction (amusingly the location is also typed, but then X'ed out - no doubt for national security reasons). Across the top it reads: Japanese Hunting License. Free ammunition. No bag limit.

I suspect they don't hand out things like that anymore when folks sign up...

Myself, my father, and my grandfather all have the same first name, last name, and middle initial (although different middle names).

My dad gave me a set of his dog tags from Vietnam (USAF @ Tan Son Nhut '67-69), which are also king of cool since we have essentially the same name and share blood type. But I've never worn them anywhere. Wouldn't want something to happen to them. Just like them as an artifact of history.

Insofar as you wearing yours, do it if you want. Anyone asks tell them the story. I think people should only have a problem with it if you tried to pass yourself off as having been at the Battle of the Bulge.
 
Like another poster said. I have my grandfathers marine pic up on the wall with his cover (hat) inside the frame with his folded flag below it that we got when he died. When people come over they see it and always ask.
Posted from Rivals Mobile
 
Can you post a picture of them? First of all, I don't think they even look like modern doc tags. Second, where them if you want, people spend too much time worrying about what other people think, you e got a great story to tell.

If it were me I'd probably get them framed or something.
 
i suppose it is a personal choice. Mine are in a drawer somewhere my wife thinks I should display them. I served but I don't really identify with being a Veteran except on Veterans Day I will eat at Golden Corral.
 
22 years Army here!

With a long line of history in your family. Wear them proudly and if asked tell that story. You must tell their story. They are the soldiers that over the way for all of us veteran. Their sacrifices and honor must be told.

My opinion!! Wear them with honor as the men that the belong to did!!

RLTW
SGM


Posted from Rivals Mobile
 
Originally posted by jaimeguarino:
22 years Army here!



With a long line of history in your family. Wear them proudly and if asked tell that story. You must tell their story. They are the soldiers that over the way for all of us veteran. Their sacrifices and honor must be told.



My opinion!! Wear them with honor as the men that the belong to did!!



RLTW

SGM





Posted from Rivals Mobile

I have a cool picture with your tour of duty medallions you gave me. I would take a picture and put it on here but I'm not home. Hope to see you soon.
Posted from Rivals Mobile
 
Originally posted by jamnolfin:
Originally posted by jaimeguarino:
22 years Army here!



With a long line of history in your family. Wear them proudly and if asked tell that story. You must tell their story. They are the soldiers that over the way for all of us veteran. Their sacrifices and honor must be told.



My opinion!! Wear them with honor as the men that the belong to did!!



RLTW

SGM





Posted from Rivals Mobile

I have a cool picture with your tour of duty medallions you gave me. I would take a picture and put it on here but I'm not home. Hope to see you soon.
Posted from Rivals Mobile


That is great to know my friend. I hope the family is well and we are trying to get to tally for the spring game. I had what I was told should be my last back surgery. Number 7. So we are trying. Give my best to the family!!!

Your friend

SGM
Posted from Rivals Mobile
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT