ADVERTISEMENT

Tell me about pellet grills/smokers

OrlandNole

Veteran Seminole Insider
Nov 29, 2003
31,983
3,140
853
I've used charcoal grills for most of my life, but considering the jump to a pellet grill. For those of you who have used them, what can you tell me about them?

Are they easy to clean/maintain?
Are they easy to fire up and use on a regular (several times per week) basis?
Is the taste/quality similar to charcoal?
How expensive are pellets relative to charcoal?

Thanks!
 
I know people who have pellet smokers. The ease of use is their main attribute. Personally, I don't think the quality of the smoke is comparable to stick wood.
 
They are great in my opinion. I keep a Weber kettle grill on hand too. The pellet grill is super for ease of use and makes some really good food. I enjoy my burgers more on it than the grill too as they come out super juicy. I've done whole chickens, chicken breasts, pork ribs, pork butts/shoulders and beef brisket and have been pleased with all.

I like the Weber for when I still want direct heat such as getting a sear. I reverse sear my steaks so I go from smoker to grill right at the end. I also will use kettle for smoking fish, especially salmon with skin on a side. The direct heat is not a big deal with the scales on and I can create way more smoke. I just prefer some fish (mainly salmon) done at a higher temp (I let a little brown sugar melt and caramalize on top) and I can infuse way more smoke with a bunch of chips mixed in to the charcoal.

They are a little bit of a pain to clean but not too bad. After every 3-4 uses I pull the 2 main pieces where I can vacuum all the pellet dust as you don't want it to start flying around inside and get on the food. I keep heavy grade aluminum foil wrapped on the drip tray and I swap that every 8-10 uses or depending how messy it's getting based on what I've cooked.

I've smoked the traditional way as well and tasted food from plenty of others who smoke stuff more "traditionally" and my food from the pellet grill tastes as good or better. It's easier to maintain consistent temp and that's the key in any type of smoking. I get a great smoke ring too. The biggest disadvantage is when you want a heavier volume of smoke than it puts out but, you can also buy external pellet holders to place in the unit to create more smoke if you wanted. I never have since I use my Weber when I want something on occasion with more volume of smoke, as I mentioned. You'll smoke stuff way more often with one than you would with a traditional smoker just because it's so easy. I don't think about the expense of the pellets much. A bag is pricier than charcoal but, I get a lot more cook time.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Imtotallynottribe
A traditional wood smoker is better, but who has time for all that? I have a Cabelas brand pellet smoker, and I will probably always have one the rest of my life. Only thing I would have done differently is get the biggest one, I got the medium sized one.
 
Not a fan. Comp folks in Florida love them, but hard pass. Too little smoke flavor, has to be covered, and pellets are a pain. Fine for the average back yard cook, but so many better options.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DFSNOLE
Meat smoked with pellets tastes like chemicals to me...
 
Not at my house. My wife asked if I wanted her to get some steaks and cook them for Father's Day. I told her she could get them but I would be doing the cooking.

Good stuff. Is that your picture on the Brawny towel wrapper? :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: noleit
Pellet grills are fantastic. Plenty of smoke flavor. Only reason not to get one is if you are in competition or just love tending to the smoker all day. But I've seen pellet smokers win plenty of comps too. Meat is just as tender as the non pellet smokers. Spend $700 on one and call it a day.
 
I've cooked on traditional wood smoker. The pellet smoker tastes as good if you are patient and know what you are doing. You see more and more of them in competitions. Don't be discouraged by anyone knocking the taste. A lot of times people who enjoy the art of smoking, which can be a lot of fun, do not want to accept that technology can allow the same work to be done for them. Good smoking is about maintaining proper temp and this allows you to do that and it gives plenty of smoke. I get a great smoke ring on meats I cook with the pellet smoker.
 
A lot of times people who enjoy the art of smoking, which can be a lot of fun, do not want to accept that technology can allow the same work to be done for them. Good smoking is about maintaining proper temp and this allows you to do that and it gives plenty of smoke.
This is like claiming you're a good driver while sitting in the back seat.
 
Guy I work with makes/cooks with some sort of ceramic grill. Can't remember what he called them, but they look pretty cool. As for me I am your $399 Lowes grill every decade or so kind of guy.
 
Guy I work with makes/cooks with some sort of ceramic grill. Can't remember what he called them, but they look pretty cool. As for me I am your $399 Lowes grill every decade or so kind of guy.
I have a Kamado Joe. Bought it at a Costco Road Show right before 4th of July last year. Got the demo model and tons of great accessories for an awesome price. Have really enjoyed learning and cooking some meats. Even did a turkey for Christmas which was amazing. With everything it takes time to understand and learn the processes which for me is half the fun.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jryan
Meat smoked with pellets tastes like chemicals to me...

I would guess this is from two things. Either you tasted meat cooked in a brand new unit and are tasting the manufacturing oily film that should have been burned off, seasoned for 45 minutes, before cooking or the grates in the unit has not been cleaned in a very long time and the grease inside has turned rancid and you are getting a creosote taste.

The pellet smoker if designed properly should give you a very good thin blue smoke and not the puffy white smoke that can create a bitter taste. The smoker is using convection heat and you should get a "almost" perfectly cooked meat. It cooks much better than electric due to the convection heat created with the fans and insures you don't get a temperature outside the range you want to cook that can happen with the other methods. If you compared your product to 100 other weekend cooks using other methods, you should easily be in the top 5.

Fruit pellets tend to be much lighter on smoke flavor compared to chunks and I would suggest blending it with other pellets.

What makes the pellet smoker work so well is a recipe for something to break down in the future. Make sure to buy one with a very good warranty and expect at some point in the future that either a wire connection, fan & auger motors at some point will go down. Moisture, heat, smoke, dust and grease will harm the unit over time. Companies that back their products for extended period in the future are more likely to build with better components.

I purchased a Grilla Silverback pellet smoker and have been very pleased with it design, build and function. In addition, I purchased another half top rack to go along with the one that is supplied which gives you two full racks to cook on and a cover to protect it from the elements.
 
I have no issue being chauffeured through the process to a wonderful end result. To me it's about a wonderful end product and the ease that allows me to use it more often versus bragging all the steps I took to get there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BelemNole
A lot of times people who enjoy the art of smoking, which can be a lot of fun, do not want to accept that technology can allow the same work to be done for them. Good smoking is about maintaining proper temp and this allows you to do that and it gives plenty of smoke.
This is like claiming you're a good driver while sitting in the back seat.

Not necessarily. Pellet smokers can flare up and you can have a multitude of factors that interfere with maintaining temps.

I've got 2 racks of ribs on my Traeger right now and I get just enough smoke flavor and they're not overpowering.
 
This comes up from time to time. If you want a versatile grill/smoker that you don’t have to babysit all night they’re great. If you find the pleasure in chopping down the tree, ageing the wood then tending your stick burner all night- they’re not for you.
I have a Webber kettle, a stick burner, and a pellet cooker. I haven’t used anything but the pellet cooker in probably two years. It’s just too easy and it makes good food. I can cook a brisket for 12 hours and the temp won’t vary. The next day I can put in the pizza insert and make wood fired pizzas in 2 minutes. A day later I’m making burgers on it.
Clean-up isn’t any better or worse if you get a decent brand cooker.
 
There is a whole world of smokers between Pellet Poopers and Stick Throwing. Cans, Gravity, Water Cookers, etc... If you want something that produces great quality, requires next to know babysitting, and cooks really fast look into Drum Smokers. I cook on a Deep South Gravity Fed. Mine can run for 12 hours without me thinking about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RONole
After a few off-set smokers over the years, I've had a Yoder pellet smoker for three years now and prefer the convenience. It took me a few smokes to get dialed into it but with the added smoke tube, it performs easily as good as the ones I had to constantly watch over.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BelemNole
Copied from another forum.

Here's a partial list of pellet grills:

MFG No. of Models
Black Earth (Hybrid) 1
Blaz'n 2
Brinkman 2
Cabelas (made by Camp Chef) 2
Camp Chef 6
Chargriller 1
Cook Shack 5
Danson( LG and CS ) 12
Englander 1
Firecraft 1
GMG 3
Grizzly 1
HomeComfort 1
Kuma 1
Landmann ?
Mak 3
Memphis (Hearthland) 4
Pellet Pro 2
Pit Boss 8
Pitts and Spitts 2
Rec Tec 2
Royall 8
Sawtooth 2
Smoke Hollow 1
Smokin Brothers 8
Smoke-N-Hot 5
Teton ?
Traeger 23
WoodMaster 2
Yoder 3
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT