I‘ve been to Salt Lick more often than any Texas bbq place other than Kreuz. Mainly because its Dripping Springs location is a nice semi-midway point between Austin and the bigger/better wineries in the Texas Hill Country. So my wife and I will about once a year or every other year get up in Austin and then stop at Salt Lick for lunch before moving on to the wineries and spend the night in Fredericksburg or thereabouts. It makes for a pleasant day And as you mentioned the ambiance and scenery could not be more “Texas” If they tried.
As far as the BBQ itself, it’s not bad. Like 99% of Texas BBQ places they can’t cook chicken or pork to save their life. Forget rising to the quality of great NC pulled pork, Memphis pork ribs and North Alabama chicken, Salt Lick and 99% of Texas BBQ places aren’t even as good as a Sonny’s or other chain bbq. As far as the beef goes…Salt Lick’s beef brisket and beef ribs are on par with Buccees or on par with better chains in Florida like Four Rivers and Mission. It’s definitely not Going to win best bbq beef in Central Texas. What is really good and what we usually get is the bison rib which is usually extraordinary good and the sausage. I don’t know why but Texas BBQ places can’t cook whole pork pieces and get even a mediocre outcome, but somehow their pork and pork/beef sausages or “Hot Guts” are always tremendously good.
So if anyone goes to Salt Lick they should get the bison ribs and sausages to go with the great local wine and beer.