ADVERTISEMENT

Mass shooting at Michigan State.

But let's make sure they can be armed without any regulation. Right?
You don’t get it, all those people with concealed weapons, who will require no training or license, will obviously be heroes and kill the bad guys before they commit these evil acts. I can’t wait to see shootouts in the street like the wild west. (Sarcasm font)
 
So, those in charge should just give up and do nothing but offer thoughts and prayers?

Let’s break down what I posted:

Will/have criminals always found/find ways around laws and regulations to commit crime? YES.

Should everyone stay vigilant and have a plan? ABSOLUTELY. We live in a crazy world.

Did I say those in charge should give up and do nothing? NO.

Did I offer thoughts and prayers as a solution? NO. Although I’m personally praying for those affected by this and the MSU community.
 
Last edited:
So, those in charge should just give up and do nothing but offer thoughts and prayers?
There was once a moderator who cautioned us not to be political...
What have you done with the body?

As I have stated more than once I am not a fan of guns - they scare me - but lines get drawn so quickly on this topic. Ugh.
 
But let's make sure they can be armed without any regulation. Right?
That’s you talking. Do every background check you want….and I am happy to wait 3-5-7 days (whatever) before I receive my next gun. That won’t solve the problem, but I’ve never objected to any of that. If it makes your crowd feel better, all fine. Let’s try it.
 
Let’s break down what I posted:

Will/have criminals always found/find ways around laws and regulations to commit crime? YES.

Should everyone stay vigilant and have a plan? ABSOLUTELY. We live in a crazy world.

Did I say those in charge should give up and do nothing? NO.

Did I offer thoughts and prayers as a solution? NO. Although I’m personally praying for those affected by this and the MSU community.
You're not breaking down your post, you're expanding it a lot. Will criminals always find a way? Maybe. But a lot of these crimes are committed by people who until that act, have never been a criminal before. Common sense laws may very well keep those people from committing their first. If you want to change or further explain your post, that's fine but don't claim for a second that what you're claiming in your second post was clear in the first.

Criminals will always find a way.

Stay vigilant and have a plan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BelemNole
There was once a moderator who cautioned us not to be political...
What have you done with the body?

As I have stated more than once I am not a fan of guns - they scare me - but lines get drawn so quickly on this topic. Ugh.
That person wasn't me. I have said since the reset of this board that we can and should discuss current events and if politics are part of that, so be it. When it becomes hyper partisan we have an issue.
 
No. You can own guns and believe in better controls and background checks. Those of us with permits to carry have the required checks and training. Most would agree to better ones to keep guns out of crazies hands.
That's the opposite of what is being proposed in Florida as I'm sure you're aware.
 
1. You're not breaking down your post, you're expanding it a lot. (DISAGREE - but I believe you know that and you’re simply looking for dialogue on the topic. I’ll be your huckleberry.)

2. But a lot of these crimes are committed by people who until that act, have never been a criminal before. (AGREE).

3. Common sense laws may very well keep those people from committing their first. (What type of common sense laws? I would like to see plea bargaining for gun charges go away. If you committed a felony gun charge you serve max time and no pleading down to a misdemeanor w/ time served. Judges/Attorneys bare A LOT of the responsibility for the repeated gun violence this country is dealing with. This needs to be discussed. I know that doesn’t address the first time offender committing a horrific act but the MSU shooter was not a first time offender and majority of gun violence isn’t a mass shooter.
 
1. You're not breaking down your post, you're expanding it a lot. (DISAGREE - but I believe you know that and you’re simply looking for dialogue on the topic. I’ll be your huckleberry.)
You can disagree all you want but what you included in you second post was not even referred to in the first.
2. But a lot of these crimes are committed by people who until that act, have never been a criminal before. (AGREE).
3. Common sense laws may very well keep those people from committing their first. (What type of common sense laws? I would like to see plea bargaining for gun charges go away. If you committed a felony gun charge you serve max time and no pleading down to a misdemeanor w/ time served. Judges/Attorneys bare A LOT of the responsibility for the repeated gun violence this country is dealing with. This needs to be discussed. I know that doesn’t address the first time offender committing a horrific act but the MSU shooter was not a first time offender and majority of gun violence isn’t a mass shooter.
How about a national background check? Mental health screening? National Red Flag laws? Nation wide waiting periods? Assault weapon bans (Remember Ronald Reagan? He was in favor of this.) Magazine size limits? Would any of these stop what happened in Michigan? No. But they very well may stop thousands of other deaths.
 
@DFSNOLE

Magazine size limits - It would then become magazine quantity limits.

Waiting periods - Sure but how long is the wait? Then when it happens again will we extend the waiting period further and just keep extending it?

What’s an assault weapon?

Mental Health / Background check - maybe a test like getting a drivers licenses to show your proficient and safe with a firearm. Signs that you aren’t can mean your license gets revoked just like your DL can.

Red Flag Laws - Florida has Risk Protection Order
 
There was once a moderator who cautioned us not to be political...
What have you done with the body?

As I have stated more than once I am not a fan of guns - they scare me - but lines get drawn so quickly on this topic. Ugh.
Thank you for reiterating, again, your personal in-depth perspective on guns. I know I feel better. Thanks for sharing! I do fancy Annie Oakley. She had a great six shooter she was always toting. :cool:
 
@DFSNOLE

Magazine size limits - It would then become magazine quantity limits.

Waiting periods - Sure but how long is the wait? Then when it happens again will we extend the waiting period further and just keep extending it?

What’s an assault weapon?

Mental Health / Background check - maybe a test like getting a drivers licenses to show your proficient and safe with a firearm. Signs that you aren’t can mean your license gets revoked just like your DL can.

Red Flag Laws - Florida has Risk Protection Order
Magazine size limits - It would then become magazine quantity limits. So?

Waiting periods - Sure but how long is the wait? Then when it happens again will we extend the waiting period further and just keep extending it? It's something to be decided but choosing to do nothing is also a choice.

What’s an assault weapon? Funny how it was able to be defined in 1994 in bipartisan manner.

Mental Health / Background check - maybe a test like getting a drivers licenses to show your proficient and safe with a firearm. Signs that you aren’t can mean your license gets revoked just like your DL can. It should go beyond proficiency with the weapon itself. IMO

Red Flag Laws - Florida has Risk Protection Order Which will be rendered moot by the proposed no permit conceal carry law.
 
Last edited:
The population of crazy and imbalanced people continues to grow. Folks growing up in fractured environments with no proper parenting, structure, discipline, love, etc.
Actually, they have always been there. Sure it waxes and wanes somewhat, but it you look at most metrics it has actually gone down since 1990. I preface the rest of my post under the assumption that depression/suicide/mental health issues are endemic and will remain with us.

These conversations tend to be more emotional and lacking in specification. Gun Violence comes in several iterations. You have the personal ones, where the shooter and victim are well known to each other. You have the economic ones, where there is money being contested like in the drug trade and then you have the mass events like we just saw. Each type has a different genesis and differing options to reduce.

Each of these types are made worse by the amount and intensity of the weapons available.

Without access to "military style" semi-automatic weapons with specialized bullets the later (mass events) is severely contained.

But, we already have a ton of this type of weapons and bullets on the street.

Personal violence has always been with us and is hard to contain because it can be done with one's hands or a knife, etc. So probably will always be with us.

Economic gun violence can be contained, but we need to take away the "profits." Legalization and regulation of drugs would go a long way in reducing this.

The question has always been are we, as a country willing to act in ways to reduce gun violence? So far the answer is no..............we know what needs to be done, but politically can't make it happen.

So we talk in circles around it, hand wring, and it just continues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NoleFan2U
Without access to "military style" semi-automatic weapons with specialized bullets the later (mass events) is severely contained.
The VT killer took 32 lives with a pair of handguns.


During February and March 2007, Cho began purchasing the weapons that he later used during the killings. On February 9, Cho purchased his first handgun, a .22 caliber Walther P22 semi-automatic pistol, from TGSCOM Inc., a federally licensed firearms dealer based in Green Bay, Wisconsin, and the operator of the website through which Cho ordered the gun.[84][85][86][87] TGSCOM Inc. shipped the Walther P22 to JND Pawnbrokers in Blacksburg, Virginia, where Cho completed the legally required background check for the purchase transaction and took possession of the handgun.[88]On March 13, Cho bought his second handgun, a 9mm Glock 19 semi-automatic pistol, from Roanoke Firearms, a licensed gun dealer located in Roanoke, Virginia.[84][89]

Cho was able to pass both background checks and successfully complete both handgun purchases after he presented to the gun dealers his U.S. permanent residency card, his Virginia driver's permit to prove legal age and length of Virginia residence and a checkbook showing his Virginia address, in addition to waiting the required 30-day period between each gun purchase. He was successful at completing both handgun purchases because he did not disclose on the background questionnaire that a Virginia court had ordered him to undergo outpatient treatment at a mental health facility.
 
So we talk in circles around it, hand wring, and it just continues.
Because the laws being proposed are being put forth as a 100% solution to prevent them from happening which is the wrong way of going about it and it only gets active discussions after a tragedy. The proposals should be happening without it being on the heels of a tragedy and not proposed as 100% solutions and instead just common sense to reduce risk not eliminate risk.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DFSNOLE
Interesting discussion.

Here's another wrinkle. The shooting near the Circle K on Bannerman.

The person that died was the instigator of the shooting. He had done this before and was required to take anger management classes, yet he does it again.

After the first time, should he have been allowed to still carry?
 
Interesting discussion.

Here's another wrinkle. The shooting near the Circle K on Bannerman.

The person that died was the instigator of the shooting. He had done this before and was required to take anger management classes, yet he does it again.

After the first time, should he have been allowed to still carry?

That's the point.. Was he carrying his gun legally or illegally? I don't know the case so I am asking.

If he were carrying the gun illegally, then theres where the rub is.. People do illegal things all of the time. How do you stop that?
 
That’s you talking. Do every background check you want….and I am happy to wait 3-5-7 days (whatever) before I receive my next gun. That won’t solve the problem, but I’ve never objected to any of that. If it makes your crowd feel better, all fine. Let’s try it.
You do realize the state of FL is doing the exact opposite of that, right?
 
That's the point.. Was he carrying his gun legally or illegally? I don't know the case so I am asking.

If he were carrying the gun illegally, then theres where the rub is.. People do illegal things all of the time. How do you stop that?
Carrying legally, but after having had a road rage incident before, and having attended anger management classes.
 
The VT killer took 32 lives with a pair of handguns.


During February and March 2007, Cho began purchasing the weapons that he later used during the killings. On February 9, Cho purchased his first handgun, a .22 caliber Walther P22 semi-automatic pistol, from TGSCOM Inc., a federally licensed firearms dealer based in Green Bay, Wisconsin, and the operator of the website through which Cho ordered the gun.[84][85][86][87] TGSCOM Inc. shipped the Walther P22 to JND Pawnbrokers in Blacksburg, Virginia, where Cho completed the legally required background check for the purchase transaction and took possession of the handgun.[88]On March 13, Cho bought his second handgun, a 9mm Glock 19 semi-automatic pistol, from Roanoke Firearms, a licensed gun dealer located in Roanoke, Virginia.[84][89]

Cho was able to pass both background checks and successfully complete both handgun purchases after he presented to the gun dealers his U.S. permanent residency card, his Virginia driver's permit to prove legal age and length of Virginia residence and a checkbook showing his Virginia address, in addition to waiting the required 30-day period between each gun purchase. He was successful at completing both handgun purchases because he did not disclose on the background questionnaire that a Virginia court had ordered him to undergo outpatient treatment at a mental health facility.
Reread what I said. A. the point is to reduce these types of incidents not eliminate. Semi-automatic rifles or pistols doesn't really make any difference. B. Getting deadly guns off the streets is never going to be an easy thing to accomplish as I mentioned. No easy fixes, no way to eliminate all hand gun violence. Doing nothing is the easy way out which we have chosen.
 
Magazine size limits - It would then become magazine quantity limits. So?

Waiting periods - Sure but how long is the wait? Then when it happens again will we extend the waiting period further and just keep extending it? It's something to be decided but choosing to do nothing is also a choice.

What’s an assault weapon? Funny how it was able to be defined in 1994 in bipartisan manner.

Mental Health / Background check - maybe a test like getting a drivers licenses to show your proficient and safe with a firearm. Signs that you aren’t can mean your license gets revoked just like your DL can. It should go beyond proficiency with the weapon itself. IMO

Red Flag Laws - Florida has Risk Protection Order Which will be rendered moot by the proposed no permit conceal carry law.

So how many magazines can one have and what would you set their capacity at?

What’s your ideal wait period?

What else would you add beyond proficiency with a firearm?

Risk Protection Order won’t go away with Constitutional Carry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrianNole777
Which will be rendered moot by the proposed no permit conceal carry law.
I am not for this law.

However, I think many opposed are exaggerating what the law does. It does not make it legal for people that are not allowed to own or carry guns due to being convicted felon or red flagged. It is removing the need to get a Concealed Carry Permit to carry a gun if you are otherwise legally allowed to carry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldmom
Doing nothing is the easy way out which we have chosen.
In addition to putting restrictions, why are mandatory and increased jail time punishments not also proposed for any crimes with a gun including illegally in possession of one. Is it because the belief there would be a disparate impact to minorities having to serve more jail time due to the sentences? Shouldn't we also be looking to increase the risk for people illegally carrying and possessing weapons of doing mandatory minimum jail time. Repeat offenders even more.
 
Reread what I said.
Better than that I quoted it:

Without access to "military style" semi-automatic weapons with specialized bullets the later (mass events) is severely contained.

Your hypothesis doesn’t hold up under available evidence. .22 and 9mm pistols are not “military style”, and yet Cho set the record (at that time) for victims.
 
In addition to putting restrictions, why are mandatory and increased jail time punishments not also proposed for any crimes with a gun including illegally in possession of one. Is it because the belief there would be a disparate impact to minorities having to serve more jail time due to the sentences? Shouldn't we also be looking to increase the risk for people illegally carrying and possessing weapons of doing mandatory minimum jail time. Repeat offenders even more.

Because Judges and Lawyers:
- “don’t want to clog up the court system”
-“They don’t have the man power to handle all the cases”
-“It cost too much”

How much longer will people allow these excuses from our judicial system when it comes to gun violence in America?

When it comes to weapon charges and gun violence, plea bargaining should not be an option.

Do your job.
 
There is no fix coming. America has decided it cares more about gun worship than kids. Things will only get worse.
I'm encouraging my kids to find jobs elsewhere after college.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DFSNOLE and 12Nole
There is no fix coming. America has decided it cares more about gun worship than kids. Things will only get worse.
I'm encouraging my kids to find jobs elsewhere after college.
Interesting in that you usually hear people talk about leaving the country when a president is elected that they did not vote for. Did any of your kids listen and if so where do they plan on going?
 
Because Judges and Lawyers:
- “don’t want to clog up the court system”
-“They don’t have the man power to handle all the cases”
-“It cost too much”

How much longer will people allow these excuses from our judicial system when it comes to gun violence in America?

When it comes to weapon charges and gun violence, plea bargaining should not be an option.

Do your job.
Now flip it around and list the reasons/excuses put forth by the defenders of everything desired the NRA. Like everything else in the political realm, all sides are so entrenched that not only will they not compromise but will move farther from the center.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT