ADVERTISEMENT

Now it's Peyton Manning

Status
Not open for further replies.

Finance85

Star Player
Oct 22, 2003
22,674
333
733
A former athletic trainer spoke out about the sexual harassment allegations against retired NFL quarterback Peyton Manning.

Jamie Naughright, who was an athletic trainer at Manning’s alma mater, the University of Tennessee, spoke to Inside Edition in her first television interview since the allegations began in 1996.

[Manning] “pulled his shorts down and put his anus and testicles on my face,” Naughright said on Feb. 29, 1996. The athletic trainer was examining the quarterback’s foot at the time when the alleged incident occurred.

Manning denied the allegations and insisted he was “mooning” a friend in the locker room.

The interview had an exclusive clip of Manning’s deposition, showing the then-19-year-old college quarterback telling his side of the story.

"I briefly pulled down my pants to so-called 'moon' him," Manning said in the deposition. "One second, one and a half seconds. Pulled my pants back up and continued with Jamie's examination of the bottom of my foot."

"I was repulsed. I was scared. I was intimidated," she said. "It was definitely a predator -- intimidating, anger, violent eyes that he had."

The trainer said she filed a report with a crisis center that handled sexual assault allegations and told the counselor she "feared for her job, worried and feared for her life."

“My boss, when I called him that night, really realized that this was a serious situation," Naughright said. "This was a sexual assault and he informed me not to call the police or press."


http://www.foxnews.com/entertainmen...out-about-alleged-sexual-harassment-case.html

Lots of issues here.

First, there's a difference in the telling of what happened. Naughright may not have been aware of what Peyton's intentions were at the time. Peyton could be lying about what his intentions were. There's no way to know.

The answer is definitely different now, but 20 years ago, would it have been expected that guys would need to change their behavior in the locker room because females were present?

Naughright said Manning had violent eyes. She feared for her job and for her life. Assuming that fear was real, was it something a reasonable person would feel under the circumstances.

Naughright said it was sexual assault. This is one place I think she goes way too far, in any setting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bigmamanole
This story and lawsuit has been known for a long time UT and ESPN covered it up for their golden boy. I believe her version of being tea bagged was corroborated by witness
 
  • Like
Reactions: NoleFan2U
This has been known forever. I don't think there's any real doubt he did it. They agreed to a settlement and not to talk about it, and every time they are stupid enough to try to deny it publicly, she dings them again for more millions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BelemNole
teabagging-tea-bag-640x533.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: TexSkills
certainly known for a while, but he's Manning so no one likes to talk about it. For once I'd like him to be forced to actually answer to this as well as UT rather than hiding from it and deflecting.
 
certainly known for a while, but he's Manning so no one likes to talk about it. For once I'd like him to be forced to actually answer to this as well as UT rather than hiding from it and deflecting.
Exactly, people have been casting a blind eye upon this jackass because he's seen as a wholesome golden boy and does a good 'golly gee shucks' routine.

For all the crap Jameis got for something he didn't do, this guy has gotten a free pass (minus some hush money) for doing far worse.

I'm hoping now if finally becomes the pariah he ought to be.
 
Exactly, people have been casting a blind eye upon this jackass because he's seen as a wholesome golden boy and does a good 'golly gee shucks' routine.

For all the crap Jameis got for something he didn't do, this guy has gotten a free pass (minus some hush money) for doing far worse.

I'm hoping now if finally becomes the pariah he ought to be.

Just curious were you there when it happened? Do have some evidence no one else has seen? A friend that was there? I have no idea if this did or didn't happen and I have not followed this story at all other than hearing rumors. So I ask why the complete guilty assumption? I have no love for any man that does this; but I also wonder what it looks like when we give complete agreement to a person.
 
This little part is new -

Manning’s lawyer, Matthew D. McGill, released a statement to Inside Edition regarding the alleged incident.

Most recently, she left Peyton’s mother a vulgar and extremely disturbing voicemail. Ms. Naughright should stop this abusive behavior.”

Naughright said in response that she has not changed her story but did not deny that she called Manning’s mother.

"I'm on Ambien. And I had sleptwalk and somehow found that number, Naughright told Inside Edition. "And anger and Ambien is not a good combination."

Why would she call Peyton's mother? Seems to me that after all these years, that amounts to stalking. She was sleepwalking and somehow found that number? Um... ok...
 
  • Like
Reactions: FSUTribe76
This has been known forever. I don't think there's any real doubt he did it. They agreed to a settlement and not to talk about it, and every time they are stupid enough to try to deny it publicly, she dings them again for more millions.
Is she related to Jimmy Sexton??
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnnieHolmesNole
Just curious were you there when it happened? Do have some evidence no one else has seen? A friend that was there? I have no idea if this did or didn't happen and I have not followed this story at all other than hearing rumors. So I ask why the complete guilty assumption? I have no love for any man that does this; but I also wonder what it looks like when we give complete agreement to a person.

He has settled it at least twice. I believe there were witnesses.

Listen, the guy was young when it happened, he clearly thought it was a funny joke, I'm ok with the guy being forgiven given the balance of his life after that.

But it was still a horrible thing, and a bad and humiliating experience for her, and she suffered professional repercussions as well. I think it's something that a 20 year old or whatever shouldn't necessarily have to pay for their entire life, however by all indications they've (the Mannings or their surrogates or supporters) spent 20 years denying it happened and basically ruining this woman for speaking out. To me, that's why I don't hate Peyton Manning or resent his success or anything, but I also have no problem with this coming up again and again and dogging him because he's never just admitted it and apologized.

If she's harassing his family or whatever, that's no good either. She did settle the case a couple times now, that's out of bounds.
 
"I'm on Ambien. And I had sleptwalk and somehow found that number, Naughright told Inside Edition. "And anger and Ambien is not a good combination."

The Tiger Woods defense...
 
He has settled it at least twice. I believe there were witnesses.

Listen, the guy was young when it happened, he clearly thought it was a funny joke, I'm ok with the guy being forgiven given the balance of his life after that.

But it was still a horrible thing, and a bad and humiliating experience for her, and she suffered professional repercussions as well. I think it's something that a 20 year old or whatever shouldn't necessarily have to pay for their entire life, however by all indications they've (the Mannings or their surrogates or supporters) spent 20 years denying it happened and basically ruining this woman for speaking out. To me, that's why I don't hate Peyton Manning or resent his success or anything, but I also have no problem with this coming up again and again and dogging him because he's never just admitted it and apologized.

If she's harassing his family or whatever, that's no good either. She did settle the case a couple times now, that's out of bounds.

Completely agree. 20 year olds do stupid things. They should have to pay some repercussions for it, but it was essentially swept under the rug. He seems to be a good guy, assuming this stuff didn't happen anymore, and probably was just an idiot 20 year old. However a lot of grown men tried to ruin this woman and still deny it over and over to this day. There are plenty of witnesses who have corroborated that it happened. I'd simply like for the school to admit that it handled the situation improperly, offer an apology, and move on.
 
Completely agree. 20 year olds do stupid things. They should have to pay some repercussions for it, but it was essentially swept under the rug. He seems to be a good guy, assuming this stuff didn't happen anymore, and probably was just an idiot 20 year old. However a lot of grown men tried to ruin this woman and still deny it over and over to this day. There are plenty of witnesses who have corroborated that it happened. I'd simply like for the school to admit that it handled the situation improperly, offer an apology, and move on.

Exactly. This woman was victimized by what I'm sure he thought was a silly prank, but her experience has been highly compounded by their coverup and retributions from the Mannings and U of Tennessee and their fans. And they paid anyway. Take the hit, make good, and move on.

I'm sure the original push to cover it up was exacerbated because it was pre-draft, but they doubled down in their book, and that was their big mistake. The book could have owned up to it and apologized and made a positive statement about it, considering all the good will Peyton had built up and the fact that folks generally can see he's a pretty good guy. The fact that they talked about her in the book (and had to pay her again as a result) makes me less sympathetic to whatever comes his way on this.
 
He has settled it at least twice. I believe there were witnesses.

Listen, the guy was young when it happened, he clearly thought it was a funny joke, I'm ok with the guy being forgiven given the balance of his life after that.

But it was still a horrible thing, and a bad and humiliating experience for her, and she suffered professional repercussions as well. I think it's something that a 20 year old or whatever shouldn't necessarily have to pay for their entire life, however by all indications they've (the Mannings or their surrogates or supporters) spent 20 years denying it happened and basically ruining this woman for speaking out. To me, that's why I don't hate Peyton Manning or resent his success or anything, but I also have no problem with this coming up again and again and dogging him because he's never just admitted it and apologized.

If she's harassing his family or whatever, that's no good either. She did settle the case a couple times now, that's out of bounds.

I get that and if she was paid for whatever happened she should just except that and move on. If the Mannings are still doing stuff to her then maybe that opens it up again. My issue is how stuff from decades ago comes back on people who by pure circumstance have money. I also wonder for those that are on here whether you look at it logically or are the extreme on either side did something in college 10, 20, 30 or more years where someone could come back after you and make you pay for it. I am sure no one here hooked up with a really drunk chick, got a chick to drink more than she should have, watched buddy do the same thing and I have no doubt many on here did things that today would be considered criminal. This is really the crux of many issues right now; we are applying today's standards and norms to things that happened a long time ago. That is fine if you want to just remember we all did things decades ago that today would not be viewed in a very positive light; so careful for what you wish for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Finance85
I had the same response. Neither I nor any of my friends did any of those things, and it's pretty terrifying and disgusting that anybody would think that those things are normal or acceptable.

Fair enough you 2 were angles in college. I went to FSU 91-93 and was 28 at the time I graduated. Never did frat stuff, really didn't party, lived in Killeran so for me FSU was a task to complete and move on. I did hear guys talk, had some traditional college age friends that would tell stories and met a bunch of college age girls who also had all kinds of stories that mostly revolved around alcohol and hooking up. Maybe they were all embellishing to sound cool to the older guy. I did play Rugby at FSU and heard plenty of stories about people doing things that if put into todays standards would get those involved in trouble.
 
I had the same response. Neither I nor any of my friends did any of those things, and it's pretty terrifying and disgusting that anybody would think that those things are normal or acceptable.
OK Mooning people is inappropriate.

Now the story Peyton is telling about mooning while he happened to be getting an exam sounds a little sketchy.

But are you saying you don't know anyone that has ever mooned anyone? I would have to say you are in the minority if so. I know both guys and girls that have mooned people in their younger days.
 
Exactly, I dunno what world people are living in where this type of behavior is something they or their friends engaged in or considered normal 20-30 years ago.
You never pulled the ultimate sit-up prank as a kid?

I think Manning probably thought he was being really funny in front of his teammates and didn't think about how awful and disrespectful it was to do this to a female trainer.
 
You never pulled the ultimate sit-up prank as a kid?

I think Manning probably thought he was being really funny in front of his teammates and didn't think about how awful and disrespectful it was to do this to a female trainer.
Had to google what that was, no I haven't done that. Pretty sure no matter how young I was, I wouldn't find that entertaining.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BelemNole
You never pulled the ultimate sit-up prank as a kid?

I think Manning probably thought he was being really funny in front of his teammates and didn't think about how awful and disrespectful it was to do this to a female trainer.

Gotta say, I have done similar to friends, but never to a person I don't have a relationship with or in front of someone I didn't know. I only grace my best friends with visions of my rig. :)

Gotta know your audience.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT