Just reading thru this thread and this one struck me. I was in my Sr year at FSU as an econ major and my TA tells me "well, you should go to grad school because you can't get a job with an undergrad degree in econ." Uh...you can't? No, you couldn't in 1992. Well, that's not true. I got a job, it was just a crappy one working in a bank selling car loans and Visa cards. That was a bad year to graduate, but also a bad degree to graduate with. No one mentioned that until that TA my senior year. A little late.
I ended up in econ by a circuitous route. But I came to FSU via an AA from a CC after spending some time out of college with an illness. I discovered that I got into FSU, but not a program. I took whatever business classes I could get into as a non-major and econ came easy and they were willing to take me after a year. Boom, econ major.
There's nothing wrong with FSU or another large anonymous institution like that, but what I learned from it, and told my kids as they head off to similar institutions, is that it's absolutely imperative that they have their own game plan, get their own answers (and double and triple check the answers they receive from anyone because there's no particular effort to give accurate information), watch out for their own interests at all time, do their own research about their options, double check records and credits and so forth for inaccuracies, etc. And if you can make a connection here or there in the faculty or admin that you can count on, you need to latch on and foster that relationship.
I would never count on a school like FSU (or Alabama where my daughter goes, or any similar school) to have your back, to look out for your own best interests, to give you guidance, proactively identify any causes for concern, make sure records are correct, etc. any more than does the DMV. If you're lucky and smart, you can cultivate a couple individuals that serve that role...but it's not part of the institutional culture and I'll laugh in the face of any giant state university that claims it is.
Which is fine if you know what you're doing and why at all times. If you're not prepared for that, and you don't have the parental support behind that...you can get a degree but not a whole lot of value add. For those students, I could definitely see a smaller, student-focused community as a much better transition to career and adulthood.
I will say, with the internet today, it is MUCH easier to get the information you need to call your own shots then when I was going to school. So many opportunities passed me by, not just because I didn't know, but because I didn't KNOW that I didn't know. My kids are all right, because of what I know about it now, the right questions to ask, etc. But I was not prepared and my parents weren't able to help prep me and keep me on the path.
Just another anecdote. My degree required a semester internship. I asked a couple teachers and the lady in an office how to go about getting an internship. I knew nothing other than that I needed one. I was directed to a bulletin board full of index cards.
"So just pick one off here?"
"Yep."
"How do I choose?"
"Just pick one that sounds good." All the cards had was the organization, the location, and the hours.
So I did. The internship was nothing of particular use or interest. I didn't really learn anything, I just proofread some press releases, occasionally pulled together some research. At the end of it, I inquired about full time positions after graduation...and was told no, there was never a budget or entry level role in that department for new graduates, that just wasn't an option (it was a state department that employed all of like two PR Specialist III or something like that). Ok, thanks.
So I finish that, and my final semester we have some guest speaker in one of my classes from the PR dept of the Department of Corrections. At the end of it, he introduces a girl in my class, and says that she just finished her internship with them and would be starting full time after graduation. And that his department virtually every year hired it's couple interns to full time positions.
What? So did that girl just blindly pick a different index card and get lucky? Or more likely, did she know that was a prime internship for job prospects? How did she know? Who told her? Probably, she developed a relationship with some professor who pointed her that way, or did some kind of networking. I don't know...I didn't even know that was something out there, or how to find it. "Pick a card" was what I was told by some Receptionist I making $8/hr, and I took it at that. Pulling the wrong index card off a bulletin board literally changed the course of my career and life. All I had for parental guidance ahead of time was "I think your internship usually hires you after you graduate. I think."
If you're not prepared to make your own breaks and be resourceful enough to make it happen, it's not going to just happen there. Which isn't necessarily a bad lesson for life at all, but potentially a very costly one.